Classical sexism

What was it like being a lady in Ancient Greece - a walk through the gossip, the myths and the arts.

 

Ancient Greece (the one which in elementary school is summed up to philosophy and 3 types of columns) was extremely hostile to its women. Aristotle used to say, “as between the sexes, the male is by nature superior and the female inferior, the male ruler and the female subject.”

‘Aristotle and Phyllis’, by Matthaus Zasinger, Germany, c1500.

It is possible that Aristotle was insecure and resentful like that because he had already been shamed by a woman named Phyllis. This sassy lady was in love with Alexander the Great, when she heard that Aristotle was advising her babe, to whom he served as a tutor, not to develop feelings for any woman, especially her. Phyllis, wicked and beautiful, decided to take revenge. She decided that she would seduce Aristotle and dominate him in public agora.

On the one hand, we can say Phyllis succeeded, for she persuaded the old philosopher to be ridden by her in front of the entire city. Thus providing evidence of the power of a determined woman. On the other hand, Alexander was more than convinced that his tutor’s advice was valid: it was better not to get involved with any woman, for that could be the end of the wisest of men.

This is an apocryphal story (of suspect origin) that was popular many centuries after Antiquity during the Nordic Renaissance. The fact is: in Ancient Greece no one spent too much time thinking about women. At all.

In art, for example, women were far less represented:

Before I move on, let’s pretend you interrupt me to ask, “Oh, but what about that Venus de Milo girl, the one without arms?”

‘Venus de Milo with Drawers’, by Salvador Dalí, 1936. Copyright Salvador Dalí, Fundació Gala- Salvador Dalí / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York, 2018.

The Venus de Milo you are referring to now lives in the Louvre. It was created between 130 and 100 BC, which means it is pretty recent considering Ancient history and art. We always remember it when thinking of Greek Art because there has been a huge controversy about its discovery, around 1820. Since then, the image of this Venus has been insanely repeated and parodied, as in the case of Salvador Dali’s sculpture and Bernardo Bertolucci’s film. Venus de Milo ended up engraved in the collective imaginary of the people as a prime example of Greek Art.

Eva Green in the movie The Dreamers, directed by Bertolucci in 2003.

From 800 BC to 300 BC, Greek female sculptures were nothing like Venus de Milo. They were called kore and were always dressed, while equivalent male sculptures, called kouros, were always nude. The women were represented dressed because the female body was not an icon for exaltation or pride as was the male. The female figures were drapery hangers.

It is strange for us to imagine a society where the female body does not receive excessive attention. We are very habituated to seeing it overly exposed and almost always according to predefined beauty standards. But the fact is that this was a society with a different kind of misogyny. Art, then, was made neither by nor for women. Instead of looking at the female body in the wrong ways as it happens nowadays, they did not look at all. Women were invisible.

Other depictions of the nude female body began to appear in Greek Art only after Praxisteles, the Athenian sculptor of Cnidus Aphrodite, in 300 BC, broke with tradition by representing his Venus without clothing. Take a look at her below. She is clearly embarrassed because of the swollen ankles her restorer gave her:

Cnidus Aphrodite. Marble, Roman copy after a Greek original from the 4th century. Original elements: torso and tights; restored elements: head, arms, legs and support (drapery an jug).


Now the Greeks did have brave, physically powerful female characters. Yes, they undoubtedly did. But let's put our abilities of critical thinking to test. Please? I've literally never asked you anything.

In Greek Mythology we have a handful of sisters that really cannot help us restore faith in girl power: we have Pandora, responsible for releasing all the evil of the universe from the inside of a box. And Juno, who blamed all the women in the world for the infidelity of her husband, Zeus.

Then Athena was a very complicated goddess. On the one hand, everyone loved Athena. They gave her the Parthenon at the top of the Acropolis. They gave her name to the city. Athena was wise, she was reasonable, she was a good warrior, she knew all about the arts. And to compensate for so many attributes considered masculine, she also knew how to sew, she was sensitive and she was a virgin.

But even beloved Athena could be a pain in the ass sometimes. Like that one time when Poseidon raped the priestess Medusa and Athena got upset because Medusa could not manage to stop the advances of the god. Yes, don't get me started: she blamed the victim for being raped. Athena transformed the priestess in the monster with snakes in the hair that we know today and cursed Medusa to turn every man she looks at into stone. Also, in the end, Medusa was assassinated by Perseus with the help of Athena herself.

Still think Athena was a nice person?

Moving on we have the goddess Artemis. A hunter, an independent woman who easily resisted men and motherhood. A very difficult paragon of virtue to be followed by young Athenian girls, since, to paraphrase my friend Cher, most women like men. And dessert, but that is beside the point.

Finally, the Greeks also had the amazing amazons: they rode well, shot well, sailed well. Their fierceness frightened men. Girls imitating dudes. Heavens! Such outrage, what a perversion! Then, in art we frequently find images of men defeating these women who dared to mount and shoot as well as they did.

For the women who watched these images, only one message: know what you get if you behave like an amazon.


Now we are getting to the end of this tour (I smile at the thought of your lamenting sounds).

I've written of Aristotle, Phyllis, Venus, some mythology… and honestly I do not know how to wrap a conclusion this time. With an optimistic outcome, perhaps? Perhaps. But could we say that gender inequality is a problem of the past? Nah. That misogyny is no more? Nah. I will forget about the optimistic message.

Maybe you did not know about the sexism the women of ancient Athens had to endure, but do you know who knew? Chico Buarque. So I recommend you a great Brazilian song (loaded with Chicobuarquesque irony) for your next five minutes.

Previous
Previous

Rape Portraits